SAN ANGELO, Texas — The San Angelo Police Officers Coalition is calling on San Angelo Mayor Brenda Gunter to reconsider her comments about citation revenues from San Angelo Police officers.
On Friday, the SAPOC issued a statement denouncing Gunter's comments during in the San Angelo City Council's budget meeting.
Gunter said (beginning at approximately the 20:28 mark in the recorded video):
"We all understand that we can’t do quotas, but my assumption is the following….that we couldn’t have quotas in ’18 either…..Fiscal Year ’18, right?
So we’ve never been able to set quotas so the five-year trend is reflective of never setting quotas. New laws which have impacted issues, and yet we’re seeing a million seven increase in number of citations, warnings and revenue, so the fund keeps picking up those dollars and having to cover those dollars and that is an issue.”
The letter, signed by SAPOC President Noel Anderson, said the officers in the coalition ask Gunter to change her view on the basis for which citations or warnings are issued.
It reads as follows:
"On August 29, 2023, COSA Mayor Brenda Gunter spoke during the General Fund Budget Meeting and indicated that the Police Officers of the City of San Angelo do not generate enough revenue through traffic citations. Mayor Gunter made the complaint that the General Fund is having to pick up more of the budget for Public Safety because the Citation count is down and stated "And that's an issue".
Quotas have been forbidden in Texas for decades and for good reason.
According to an article published by the Texas Municipal Courts Education Center:
Revenue generated by Class C Misdemeanors should be viewed by city officials as an INCIDENTAL BYPRODUCT of Law Enforcement and Court Operations. Traffic quotas undermine the traffic safety and public confidence in Law Enforcement and local Courts.
All local governments are legally prohibited from having traffic offense quotas according to section
720.002 of the Transportation Code which states: "prohibits formally or informally establishing a plan to evaluate, promote, compensate, or discipline a peace officer or judge based on the number of citations issued or fines collected."
Traffic Safety is a compelling public interest. The integrity of Law Enforcement and Municipal Courts in Texas hinges on maintaining public confidence that fairness, justice, public safety, and the rule of law, not revenue generation, are the reasons Class C misdemeanors (crimes punishable by the imposition of a fine) exist. Most public servants are committed to reflecting on their role in government and promoting the public's interests. Public Officials and employees who either enable or perpetrate traffic quotas do not serve the public's interest. It is an abuse of public confidence that cannot be tolerated in any City Hall by those truly committed to serving the public's interest."
In the interest of Public Trust, funding from Citations should not be an issue. Perhaps Mayor Gunters agenda should put Public Safety first.
The point to Traffic Enforcement is Public Safety, and that is it. For the current fiscal year, San Angelo Police Officers have made around 20,000 traffic stops which resulted in dispositions ranging from verbal or written warnings, citations, or arrests. Which was approximately around 18% of the total calls for service.
Revenue from citations should never be considered as a funding source for how the City budgets and/or pays its Police Officers. We feel the Mayor implied that if we want more equipment or larger salaries then the citizens should be punished by the Police through fines.
It is unfortunate that Local Law Enforcement, because of the Mayors irresponsible comments, have now been placed in a position lending to potential public distrust in the intention of the issuance of traffic citations. The Mayors comments related to discretionary enforcement have put some of the trust that the Department has built with the community in jeopardy.
The Officers of SAPOC encourage Mayor Gunter to change her view on the basis for which citations or warnings are issued."
FOX West Texas reached out to Mayor Brenda Gunter Friday for comment and has not yet received a response.
SAPOC has also been contacted and President Noel Anderson will give a statement next week regarding the situation.
This is a developing story. More information will be posted as it becomes available.
Here is the COSA special meeting SAPOC refers to in its letter: